Craving the best pizza in Naperville? Our guide reveals the top 10 pizzerias, with details, reviews, and tips to find your perfect slice in Illinois.

When pizza cravings hit, the last thing you want is to waste time scrolling endlessly trying to find the best pizza near you. You want something delicious, trustworthy, and worth every bite—and that’s exactly why “Find Your Slice: Top 10 Pizza Places in Naperville, Illinois” was created. We bring together Naperville’s top local pizza spots, featuring real video highlights, genuine customer reviews, and honest ratings to help you find your perfect slice in minutes. Whether you’re craving classic comfort or bold new flavors, discovering the best pizza in town has never been this easy

1. Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria

Website: www.loumalnatis.com

Address: 1310 N Napery Blvd, Naperville, IL 60563

Phone: (630) 717-0700

Email: cateringnaperville@loumalnatis.com

A legendary name in Chicago-style pizza, Lou Malnati’s is a must-visit for deep-dish aficionados. Their signature butter crust, lean sausage, and vine-ripened tomato sauce create a rich, iconic pie that’s worth the wait. The atmosphere is family-friendly and bustling, perfect for a classic pizza experience.

Google Review Highlights: Reviewers consistently praise the “authentic Chicago deep dish” and the “flaky, buttery crust.” Many note it’s their “go-to for out-of-town guests” wanting a true taste of the region. The efficient service for both dine-in and carry-out is also frequently commended.

2. Giordano’s

Website: https://giordanos.com/

Address: 505 E North Ave, Naperville, IL 60563

Phone: (630) 548-2800

Email: naperville@giordanos.com

Giordano’s is the other heavyweight in the stuffed pizza arena. Famous for its golden, flaky crust and layers of cheese and toppings, their pizza is a hearty, indulgent masterpiece. They also offer a wide menu of thin-crust pizzas, pastas, and sandwiches, ensuring there’s something for everyone.

Google Review Highlights: Patents rave about the “incredible stuffed spinach pizza” and call it the “definition of comfort food.” The “consistent quality” across locations and the “great group dining” options are also major plus points for reviewers.

3. Little Pops Pizza

Website: https://www.littlepopspizzeria.com/

Address: 1292 S Napery Blvd, Naperville, IL 60540

Phone: (630) 995-0005

Email: info@littlepopspizza.com

For a change of pace, Little Pops Pizza offers exceptional New York-style thin crust. Their giant, foldable slices and whole pies are a hit with those craving a lighter, crispier base. The no-frills, counter-service setup focuses on what matters most: high-quality, delicious pizza by the slice or pie.

Google Review Highlights: Customers love the “huge, authentic NY-style slices” and the “perfect thin and crispy crust.” It’s often described as the “best late-night spot” with a “cool, casual vibe.” The generous portion sizes get repeated mentions.

4. Uncle Pete’s Pizza

Website: http://www.unclepetespizza.com

Address: 1292 N Napery Blvd, Naperville, IL 60563

Phone: (630) 922-0600

Email: contact@unclepetespizza.com

A beloved local staple, Uncle Pete’s serves up fantastic Chicago-style thin crust, cut tavern-style into squares. Their sauce is notably zesty, and the toppings are always fresh. It’s the quintessential neighborhood pizzeria with a loyal following for both dine-in and delivery.

Google Review Highlights: Locals call it a “hidden gem” with the “best thin crust in town.” Reviewers highlight the “perfectly tangy sauce” and “crispy, well-done crust.” Many note it’s their family’s “weekly pizza tradition” due to its reliability and flavor.

5. Meson Sabika

Website: https://www.mesonsabika.com/

Address: 1025 Aurora Ave, Naperville, IL 60540

Phone: (630) 983-3000

Email: info@mesonsabika.com

This is not your typical pizza joint, but their tapas-style “Spanish pizza” is a unique and must-try experience. Set in a gorgeous historic mansion, Meson Sabika offers a romantic, upscale setting. Their pizzas, like the signature Jarmon Serrano y Quest de Cobra, are thin, elegant, and full of sophisticated flavors.

Google Review Highlights: Diners are enamored with the “beautiful, unique setting” and the “creative, gourmet pizzas.” The “perfect date night spot” and “excellent tapas alongside great pizza” are common themes in the reviews.

6. Bricks Wood-Fired Pizza

Website: https://brixxpizza.com/

Address: 1767 Quincy Ave #146, Naperville, IL 60540

Phone: (630) 470-2600

Email: naperville@brickswoodfiredpizza.com

True to its name, Bricks uses a wood-fired oven to create Neapolitan-style pizzas with a characteristically charred, blistered crust. The ingredients are fresh and high-quality, and the pizzas cook in just minutes. The modern, industrial-chic atmosphere adds to the authentic artisan feel.

Google Review Highlights: Reviewers highlight the “authentic wood-fired flavor” and “perfectly chewy, charred crust.” The “fresh mozzarella” and “creative specialty pies” receive high praise. It’s often labeled as the “best artisan pizza in Naperville.”

7. Dynic’s Pizza & Irish Pub

Website: https://www.dinaspizzaandpub.com/

Address: 1292 E Ogden Ave, Naperville, IL 60563

Phone: (630) 355-9400

Email: dinicos@dinicospizza.com

Dynic’s offers a cozy, pub-like atmosphere where you can enjoy a solid Chicago thin-crust pizza alongside a great pint of beer. It’s a friendly, unpretentious spot where the pizza is consistently good, the service is warm, and the vibe is welcoming for sports fans and families alike.

Google Review Highlights: Patents appreciate the “great combo of good pizza and a good pub.” The “friendly staff” and “perfect bar pizza” are frequently mentioned. It’s noted as a “reliable spot for carry-out or watching the game.”

8. Amoretti’s of Naperville

Website: https://www.amorettis.com.au/

Address: 55 S Main St, Naperville, IL 60540

Phone: (630) 355-2800

Email: info.naperville@morettis.com

Located in a historic building on Main Street, Amoretti’s offers a fantastic ambiance alongside its menu. They serve a robust Chicago-style thin crust that’s hearty and satisfying. With a large menu featuring Italian classics and a great patio, it’s ideal for a lively dinner out.

Google Review Highlights: Customers love the “historic, fun atmosphere” and “great downtown location.” The “crispy thin crust” and “generous toppings” are praised, along with the “excellent patio for people-watching” in the summer.

9. Beggars Pizza

Website: https://www.beggarspizzagary.com/

Address: 955 W 75th St, Naperville, IL 60565

Phone: (630) 778-9333

Email: naperville@beggars.com

Beggars Pizza is a South Side Chicago institution known for its pan pizza—a perfect middle ground between deep-dish and thin crust. It’s thick, golden, and loaded with cheese. Their wide variety of specialty pizzas, like the famous "Beggars Banquet," makes ordering a feast.

Google Review Highlights: Fans swear by the “thick, cheesy pan pizza” and call it a “Chicago classic.” The “Beggars Banquet” specialty pizza is a crowd favorite. Reviewers note it’s “always a hit for parties” and family gatherings.

10. Whole Foods Market - Pizza Department

Website: https://www.wholefoodsmarket.co.uk/

Address: 2607 W 75th St, Naperville, IL 60564

Phone: (630) 579-7000

Email: (Use Contact Form on Website)

Don’t overlook the pizza counter at Whole Foods! Offering exceptional value and quality, they make fresh, artisanal pizzas with high-end ingredients you can see. From classic cheese to seasonal specials, it’s a fantastic option for a quick, delicious, and surprisingly gourmet take-and-bake or by-the-slice meal.

Google Review Highlights: Shoppers are consistently impressed with the “high-quality ingredients for a great price.” The “take-and-bake option” is hailed as a “weeknight lifesaver.” Many say it’s the “best quick pizza option” that doesn’t compromise on taste.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q: Which Naperville pizzeria is best for deep-dish pizza?

A: Both Lou Malnati’s and Giordano’s are iconic for their authentic, indulgent Chicago-style deep-dish and stuffed pizzas.

Q: Where can I find New York-style pizza in Naperville?

A: Little Pops Pizza is the top spot for large, foldable, thin-crust New York-style slices and whole pies.

Q: Is there a gourmet or artisan pizza option in town?

A: Yes, Bricks Wood Fired Pizza offers excellent Neapolitan-style pies, and Meson Sabika provides unique, upscale Spanish-inspired pizzas.

Menu

Find Your Slice: Top 10 Pizza Places in Naperville, Illinois

Comments