Find the top 10 insurance agencies in Aurora, IL. Our guide lists trusted providers for auto, home, business, and life insurance, with verified contact details and reviews.

Securing the right insurance is a fundamental step in protecting your family, your assets, and your future in Aurora, Illinois. Whether you're looking for auto, home, business, or life insurance, navigating the myriad of policies and providers can be overwhelming. You need an agent who is not just a salesperson but a trusted advisor who understands your unique needs. This guide to the Top 10 Insurance Agencies in Aurora, Illinois, features the area's most reputable and client-focused agencies. We provide verified contact details, areas of specialization, and insights from the community to help you find an insurance partner you can rely on for years to come.

1. Allstate - Tammy Bock Agency

A well-established Allstate agency known for its friendly, community-focused service. Agent Tammy Bock and her team provide personalized policies for auto, home, life, and business, emphasizing local customer care.

Website: Tammy Bock Allstate Agency
Address: 1260 N. Lake St, Aurora, IL 60506
Phone: (630) 892-290
Email: tbock@all

Google Review Highlights:

4.5 stars—"Switched my auto and home insurance here and couldn't be happier. Tammy found us better coverage at a lower rate and is always available to answer any question. It truly feels like a neighborhood agency."

2. State Farm - Maribel Rodriguez Agency

A highly rated State Farm agency offering a comprehensive suite of insurance and financial services. Agent Maribel Rodriguez is praised for her bilingual service and diligent support through claims and policy reviews.

Website: Maribel Rodriguez State Farm Agency
Address: 1444 N. Farnsworth Ave, Suite 116, Aurora, IL 60505
Phone: (630) 585-3100
Email: maribel@maribelrodriguez.com

Google Review Highlights:

"Maribel handled my car accident claim seamlessly. She guided me through every step and made sure I was treated fairly. Her team's follow-up is exceptional. Highly recommend for Spanish and English speakers."

3. American Family Insurance - The Haag & Associates Agency

A leading American Family Insurance agency serving Aurora families and businesses for years. They are known for their expertise in bundling auto, home, and life policies for optimal value and protection.

Website: Haag & Associates AmFam Agency
Address: 2055 98th St, Suite 102, Aurora, IL 60502
Phone: (331) 212-436
Email: kevin.ha 2@amfam.com

Google Review Highlights:

"Kevin Haag saved us a significant amount by reviewing and bundling our policies. He's proactive about checking for new discounts and makes sure our coverage keeps up with our life changes."

4. Country Financial - Bryan Mueller Agency

A trusted Country Financial agency focused on building long-term financial security. Agent Bryan Mueller provides personalized strategies combining property & casualty insurance with life insurance and retirement planning.

Website: Bryan Mueller Country Financial
Address: 955 N. Lake St, Aurora, IL 60506
Phone: (630) 844-7800
Email: bryan.mueller@countryfinancial.com

Google Review Highlights:

"Bryan provides a holistic approach. He didn't just sell us insurance; he helped create a full protection plan for our family's future. Knowledgeable, patient, and incredibly thorough."

5. Goosehead Insurance - The DelAngel Agency

A franchise of the national Goosehead Insurance agency, offering a unique client-advocate model. They shop policies from over 100 carriers to find the best possible rates and coverage for auto, home, and more.

Google Review Highlights:

4.8 stars—"If "you want someone to truly shop for you, go here. They compared dozens of companies and found me much better home insurance coverage for less than I was paying. The service is outstanding."

6. Farmers Insurance—The Hennenfent Agency

A dedicated Farmers Insurance agency with a strong reputation for business and commercial insurance, in addition to robust personal lines. They are known for deep risk analysis and custom solutions.

Website: Hennenfent Farmers Agency
Address: 2340 Sequoia Dr, Suite 108, Aurora, IL 60506
Phone: (630) 499-2200
Email: mhennenfent@farmersagent.com

Google Review Highlights:

4.5 stars – "They insure my small retail business and my personal properties. Their risk assessment for my business was incredibly detailed, and they found gaps in my old policy I didn't know existed."

7. Freeway Insurance - Aurora Office

A national provider specializing in helping clients find affordable auto insurance, including SR-22 filings and high-risk coverage. They are a practical solution for drivers seeking budget-friendly, legally compliant policies.

Google Review Highlights:

4.5 stars—"Needed an SR-22 filed quickly to get my license back. They got it done in one visit at a rate I could afford. No frills, just efficient, helpful service for a stressful situation."

8. AAA - Aurora Insurance Center

Backed by the trusted AAA brand, this agency offers exclusive member benefits, including premier roadside assistance bundled with competitive auto, home, and life insurance policies.

Website: https://cluballiance.aaa.com/
Address: 4335 Fox Valley Center Dr, Aurora, IL 60504
Phone: (630) 978-260
Email: Use the contact form on their website.

Google Review Highlights:

"The bundle of AAA membership and insurance is unbeatable for peace of mind. We've used the roadside service multiple times, and our insurance rates are very competitive. Great value."

9. Nationwide - Starks Insurance Agency, Inc.

A long-standing Nationwide insurance and financial services agency. They offer the stability of a national carrier with the personalized service of a local office, specializing in farm and agribusiness coverage.

Website: Starks Insurance Nationwide
Address: 999 N. Lake St, Aurora, IL 60506
Phone: (630) 896-220
Email: info@starksinsurance.com

Google Review Highlights:

"They've insured our family farm for generations. Their understanding of agricultural risks is unparalleled. They're always responsive and fair when we've had claims due to weather."

10. Liberty Mutual - Aurora Local Office

A local branch of the national Liberty Mutual Insurance company, providing direct access to a wide range of personal and commercial insurance products with potential multi-policy discounts.

Website: Liberty Mutual Aurora
Address: 2000 Ogden Ave, Aurora, IL 60504
Phone: (630) 585-3355
Email: Contact via website.

Google Review Highlights:

"Convenient local office of a big-name company. The agent helped me customize my auto policy exactly how I wanted it and explained all the discount options clearly."

How to Choose the Right Insurance Agency in Aurora

Your choice depends on your priorities. If you value local, personalized relationships, a neighborhood agency like Tammy Bock's Allstate or Maribel Rodriguez's State Farm is ideal. For those who want an advisor to shop multiple carriers, Goosehead Insurance excels. Business owners should seek agencies with commercial expertise like Hennenfent Farmers or Starks Nationwide. AAA members will find great bundled value at their branded center. Always get quotes from at least three agencies, ask how they handle claims, and verify that they represent highly rated insurance carriers for financial stability.

FAQs on Choosing an Insurance Agency

Should I use a local independent agent or a direct carrier (like Geico online)?

A local agent provides personalized advice and advocacy during claims and can compare multiple companies, while a direct carrier may offer a streamlined, online-only experience.

What is bundling, and does it really save money?

Bundling (e.g., buying auto and home from the same company) typically results in a significant multi-policy discount, often saving 10-25%.

How often should I review my insurance policies?

You should review all policies annually or anytime you experience a major life event (marriage, new home, new teen driver, business expansion) to ensure adequate coverage.

Menu

Top 10 Insurance Agencies in Aurora Illinois

Comments